Comparing Open-Source AI Models: LLaMA 3 vs Qwen 2.5 vs Mixtral

Key Takeaways

1. Llama 3, Qwen 2.5, and Mixtral represent the current leaders in open-source language models, with Qwen 2.5 72B slightly edging out competitors on MMLU benchmarks at 86.1%.

2. Each model offers unique deployment advantages: Llama 3 features 15% more efficient tokenization, Qwen 2.5 provides flexible model sizes from 0.5B to 72B, and Mixtral achieves 6x faster inference through its sparse mixture of experts architecture.

3. For specialized capabilities, Llama 3 excels in multimodal tasks, Qwen 2.5 dominates structured data handling, and Mixtral shines in multilingual support and mathematical reasoning.

4. In technical evaluations, Llama 3.1 leads in HumanEval code generation at 80.5%, while Qwen 2.5 demonstrates superior performance in mathematical reasoning with 83.1% on MATH benchmarks.

5. Future developments include Meta pushing beyond 405B parameters for Llama models and Alibaba expanding Qwen's capabilities in tool use and agentic applications, while both focus on enhanced security features.

Last year, I started Multimodal, a Generative AI company that helps organizations automate complex, knowledge-based workflows using AI Agents. Check it out here.

The landscape of open-source large language models has dramatically evolved in the past year, with three foundation models emerging as clear leaders: Meta's Llama 3, Alibaba's Qwen 2.5, and Mixtral's sparse mixture of experts architecture. These models represent a significant leap forward in performance, efficiency, and real-world applications.

For enterprises and developers looking to leverage open weights models, understanding the nuances between these architectures is crucial. Let's dive deep into how these competing models stack up against each other across various dimensions.

Model architectures

Llama 3

- Employs a decoder-only transformer architecture with advanced grouped-query attention mechanism.

- Introduces a new tokenizer with 128K vocabulary, enabling more efficient text processing.

- Utilizes RoPE embeddings and sliding window attention for enhanced performance.

- Features specialized instruction tuning and direct preference optimization for improved output quality.

Qwen 2.5

- Built on a dense decoder-only architecture with RoPE, SwiGLU, and RMSNorm components.

- Implements attention QKV bias and tied word embeddings for better performance.

- Supports extensive multilingual capabilities across 29 languages.

- Incorporates YaRN for efficient context window extension.

Mixtral

- Features innovative sparse mixture-of-experts (MoE) architecture.

- Employs 8 expert networks with top-2 routing per layer.

- Shares attention parameters while varying feed-forward blocks.

- Uses byte-fallback BPE tokenizer for robust character handling.

Parameter scaling & efficiency

Llama 3 Series

- Scales from 1B to 405B parameters across different variants.

- 405B model trained using 16,000 H100 GPUs.

- Achieves 95% training efficiency through advanced error detection.

- Supports efficient quantization from BF16 to FP8 for deployment.

Qwen 2.5

- Ranges from 0.5B to 72B parameters with specialized variants.

- Trained on 18 trillion tokens of diverse data.

- Optimized for both high-end and edge device deployment.

- Features dedicated math and coding variants for specialized tasks.

Mixtral

- Total parameter count of 46.7B with only 12.9B active during inference.

- Achieves computation efficiency equivalent to a 13B parameter model.

- Requires 2x sequence length operations