Opinion Today: The turkeys have done nothing wrong

November 22, 2024

By Suein Hwang

Business, Economics and Technology Editor, Opinion

I still remember when the email popped up in my inbox: Peter Singer, recently described as possibly the world’s most influential living philosopher, wanted to submit a piece asking us to reconsider having turkeys on our Thanksgiving menus. When the essay came in, I opened it eagerly.

Because this aims to be a family-friendly paper, or at least not to be excessively morbid, I have spared you the details of what that piece said beyond the fact that it detailed a method used to kill entire flocks in some situations. Singer accepted our initial rejection and then turned in a very different piece that pokes fun at the presidential turkey pardon.

It is “impossible to take seriously the idea that turkeys need to be pardoned, no matter what they have done, but the annual presidential pardon is doubly absurd,” he wrote in his guest essay, “because no one has ever claimed that the turkeys sent to the president have done anything wrong — not even in the sense that your cat does something wrong when she punishes you for going on vacation by using your bed as her litter box.”

While that first, more graphic version did persuade me to mostly purge turkey from my diet, the essay we’ve published makes similar points — and you don’t have to worry about it giving your children nightmares.

Read the guest essay:

An illustration of a monochromatic Joe Biden affectionately hugging and burying his nose in a puzzled, colorful turkey.

Lukas Verstraete

Guest Essay

What a Lame Duck President Could Do for Lame Turkeys

President Biden should cancel the Thanksgiving tradition of pardoning a turkey.

By Peter Singer

Here’s what we’re focusing on today:

Editors’ Picks

A collage showing a dark figure with arms raised, silhouetted against a gray background, with a red rectangle over the midriff.

M. Gessen

What Democrats Are Getting Wrong About Transgender Rights

Trans rights aren’t just trans rights. They’re reproductive rights.

By M. Gessen

Liberals Bet They Could Beat Trump With the Law. They Lost.

A few victories made it easy for Democrats to forget that the law is just another domain of politics where their enemies enjoy power too.

By Samuel Moyn

Donald Trump, speaking to a crowd wearing a suit and tie, holds up his hands to the side of his head.

Jamelle Bouie

Trump Tries on His Crown

The Constitution is not a grant of power for a king.

By Jamelle Bouie

A grainy black-and-white photo shows Marie Gluesenkamp Perez looking pensive, with her hand to her mouth.

Michelle Goldberg

Marie Gluesenkamp Perez: ‘I Don’t Think More Lawyers Running for Office Is the Solution’

Lessons from a Democratic winner in Trump country.

By Michelle Goldberg

A black and white photograph of Elon Musk, holding a microphone and standing in front of the American flag.

Will Musk Be the Death of NASA?

SpaceX is on top right now, and, presumably, Musk wants to keep it that way.

By Neel V. Patel

The Ezra Klein Show

In This House, We’re Angry When Government Fails

The Democratic Party needs to rethink what it means to be the party of institutions.

1 HR 10 MIN LISTEN

An improvised ladder hangs from a portion the wall on the U.S.-Mexico border.

Paul Krugman

How Hostility to Immigrants Will Hurt America’s Tech Sector

Don’t assume that highly educated foreigners will be spared by the new administration.

By Paul Krugman

The Warrant for Netanyahu’s Arrest Also Implicates the United States

We should not operate as if there is some hierarchy in the value of children’s lives.

By Nicholas Kristof

john mcwhorter

The Alluring Dream That Black America Needs to Wake Up From

Cleopatra is not our mother.

By John McWhorter

A black and white photograph of Matt Gaetz.

Gaetz’s Withdrawal Means the Senate Passed Its First Test

Trump failed to push Republicans past their red line.

By Michelle Cottle

Can the Senate Survive Donald Trump?

The vaunted chamber’s degradation preceded him. But he may trash it once and for all.

By Frank Bruni

Matter of Opinion

The Road to Trump’s ‘Grand New Party’

Ross Douthat and Reihan Salam had a vision for how Republicans could reclaim the working class. They never expected Trump to fulfill it.

56 MIN LISTEN

Kenny Holston/The New York Times

letters

Matt Gaetz Bows Out, to Sighs of Relief

Readers respond to Matt Gaetz’s withdrawal. Also: Dr. Mehmet Oz and Robert F. Kennedy Jr.; Russia’s nuclear pose; political spending; election lessons; homelessness.

We hope you’ve enjoyed this newsletter, which is made possible through subscriber support. Subscribe to The New York Times .

Games Here are today’s Mini Crossword, Wordle and Spelling Bee. If you’re in the mood to play more, find all our games here.

Forward this newsletter to friends to share ideas and perspectives that will help inform their lives. They can sign up here. Do you have feedback? Email us at opiniontoday@nytimes.com.

If you have questions about your Times account, delivery problems or other issues, visit our Help Page or contact The Times.