On Politics: An adventure in democracy
Maine Democrats have a political experiment on their hands.
On Politics
July 15, 2026

Good evening. The United States and Iran are exchanging strikes for a fifth straight day. President Trump is pressuring officials with Immigration and Customs Enforcement to resume traffic stops after they pulled back following two fatal shootings.

But in politics, the big story is the Maine Senate race, where Democrats face a dilemma: How can they choose a new candidate as quickly and fairly as possible?

A picture of a lighthouse in Maine, with an American flag in the foreground.
Joe Raedle/Getty Images

An adventure in democracy

Democrats in Maine have been clear about who’s not going to select their next nominee for Senate. It won’t be Graham Platner, the disgraced ex-candidate who had hoped to have sway over the process. And it won’t be Chuck Schumer.

But it’s still not quite clear which Democrats, exactly, are going to pick the next contender.

“You have one more day to register to become a delegate,” Devon-Murphy Anderson, the executive director of the Maine Democratic Party, said in a video on social media Tuesday night.

The collapse of Platner’s campaign left Maine Democrats with a dilemma. They needed to find a new candidate quickly — but without relying on any process resembling Kamala Harris’s quick coronation after President Joe Biden’s re-election bid imploded in 2024.

What the party has set up instead will be a test of small-d democracy that is hard to explain and hard to pull off. And it just might make everybody mad anyway.

Party organizers are, in real time, standing up a county-by-county process in which registered Democrats will elect 500 delegates at county party meetings this coming weekend. Those selected, along with 101 members of the Democratic Party’s state committee who automatically got the role, will choose from a bevy of declared candidates on July 25.

The process is certainly diffuse, and no candidate appears to be an overwhelming favorite. It is also cumbersome and confusing — and it can’t, by definition, include everyone who might like to participate.

“All you can do is figure out, how do we get the broadest number of voices to participate in this that is practical?” Marcia Myers, the chair of the Hancock County Democrats, who was not involved in devising the process, told me. “What is realistic?”

“I mean,” she added, “we’re Democrats for God’s sake!”

My colleague Bayliss Wagner has an action-packed look at how candidates are honing their appeals to those state party members and maneuvering to ensure that their supporters run for the role of delegate. Their focus on such a tiny electorate is making even some of those who are part of it uncomfortable.

“Having candidates go down the list and try to get all of our votes, and then use that to become the U.S. Senate candidate when we’re such a small portion of the populace, doesn’t sit right with me,” Taylor Grant, the president of the Maine Young Democrats and a state committee member, told Bayliss.

The process is by definition open only to registered Democrats, excluding independent voters, who were an integral part of Platner’s insurgent coalition. And the only Democrats who get to participate are those willing to be part of the meetings this weekend.

“I’ve heard from a lot of people on the outside who are deeply suspicious that the Maine party, you know, is going to have this insider-controlled event,” Representative Chellie Pingree of Maine told me. She insisted that the participants would not be “insiders” but “willing volunteers” — the kind of party activists who “bake the brownies and bring the potluck meals and organize the fund-raisers and all those things.”

“I didn’t design the process,” said Pingree, whose daughter, Hannah Pingree, is the Democratic nominee for governor. “I’m just saying, you know, it was a state party faced with somewhat of an impossible challenge.”

Maine Democrats say that any Democrat who was registered as of the original June 9 primary is welcome to participate and that thousands of them have expressed interest in doing so. They say state law — and the calendar — prevents them from taking the even more inclusive step of simply holding another statewide primary.

That’s what is happening in South Carolina, where voters will choose a replacement for the late Senator Lindsey Graham on the November ballot in a special primary election next month.

Yet the winner of that election could effectively be determined by far fewer people than 601 delegates. It might just come down to the endorsement of one person: President Trump.

“What matters to the hard-core voters who are going to show up?” said Scott Huffmon, the director of the statewide Winthrop Poll. “Right now in South Carolina in 2026, the answer is, Who’s going to help push Trump’s agenda?”

Clockwise from top left, Troy Jackson, Dr. Nirav Shah, Jordan Wood and Shenna Bellows.
Clockwise from top left, Troy Jackson, Dr. Nirav Shah, Jordan Wood and Shenna Bellows.  Amanda Sabga/Reuters; Ryan David Brown for The New York Times; Graeme Sloan, via Getty Images

Who’s running in Maine?

Here are some of the most prominent Democrats who have jumped into the Senate race so far:

  • Troy Jackson, the former State Senate president and a progressive who campaigned alongside Platner
  • Dr. Nirav Shah, the former director of Maine’s public health agency
  • Shenna Bellows, the Maine secretary of state, who fought to keep President Trump off Maine’s presidential primary ballot because of his role in the Jan. 6, 2021, attack
  • Jordan Wood, a former chief of staff to former Representative Katie Porter of California
  • Dan Kleban, a brewery owner
  • David Costello, an environmental policy consultant
President Biden standing at a lectern in 2024.
Doug Mills/The New York Times

PENCIL IT IN

Nov. 17

That’s the release date of a memoir by former President Joe Biden, he announced today in a video on a social media.

Biden had originally said that the book, “Promise Me, America,” would come out in September. But that apparently offhand remark was not met warmly by Democrats, who worried that a September release would distract from their efforts to win in the midterm elections. My colleague Reid J. Epstein has more.

Got a tip?
The Times offers several ways to send important information confidentially.

ONE NUMBER

Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona at a news conference.
Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona Eric Lee for The New York Times

Nearly $25 million

That’s the war chest that Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona reported across his federal accounts. He has emerged as one of the Democratic Party’s top fund-raisers and donors in recent months as he considers a potential 2028 presidential run.

He shared his fund-raising figures with my colleague Shane Goldmacher before a federal filing deadline tonight.

A picture of a tractor at dusk
Jordan Vonderhaar for The New York Times

ONE LAST THING

The House takes a step toward making daylight saving permanent

The House on Tuesday voted overwhelmingly to make daylight saving time permanent.

Some state governments have tried for years to end the practice of turning clocks back — an effort I wrote about way back in 2017! The fate of the measure, called the Sunshine Protection Act, is now in the hands of the Senate, where at least one Republican seems poised to try to block it.

MORE POLITICS NEWS AND ANALYSIS

Susan Collins walks holding a dark folder in one arm.

Kenny Holston/The New York Times

An ICE Shooting in Maine Puts Pressure on Senator Susan Collins

The Democrats hoping to challenge Ms. Collins, a vulnerable Republican, have seized on the fatal incident, drawing attention to her record on immigration matters.

By Tim Balk

Beth Macy, author of “Dopesick,” poses in a blue print shirt.

Matt Eich for The New York Times

Can Democrats Win Rural Voters Turning Away From Trump? It’s a Tough Sell.

House candidates like Beth Macy, author of “Dopesick,” have crafted messages based on lifetimes in rural regions. But messages need an audience, and many minds are closed to the party.

By Kate Zernike

Article Image

Doug Mills/The New York Times

Trump Says He’ll Discuss Elections and Voting Machines in Speech on Thursday

The planned prime-time address comes as an administration task force has been working to declassify documents, including some related to elections, according to people familiar with the process.

By Maggie Haberman and Julian E. Barnes

Article Image

Sophie Park for The New York Times

Platner Was Toxic. But Democrats Could Learn From His Politics.

His progressive, populist message was able to occupy a kind of middle ground in the party’s primary electorate.

By Nate Cohn

Taylor Robinson contributed reporting.

Read past editions of the newsletter here.

If you’re enjoying what you’re reading, please consider recommending it to others. They can sign up here.

Have feedback? Ideas for coverage? We’d love to hear from you. Email us at onpolitics@nytimes.com.

A square filled with smaller squares and rectangles in shades of red and blue.

If you received this newsletter from someone else, subscribe here.

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for On Politics from The New York Times.

To stop receiving On Politics, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:

facebookxinstagramwhatsapp

Change Your Email