Last fall, I went to see a documentary at the Montclair Film Festival in New Jersey. I was rapt, watching the film, when I was struck with a surprise: I was in it!
The documentary was
Ask E. Jean, which follows E. Jean Carroll, from her career as a writer, to her alleged sexual assault by President Trump in the 1990s (he
was found liable for sexual abuse in 2023), to the toll of his constant insults to her $83.3 million victory against him in a defamation lawsuit. I interviewed Carroll about those same topics with her winning attorney Robbie Kaplan onstage at a
Fortune Most Powerful Women dinner in New York in 2024,
clips of which the filmmakers used to close out the doc.
Since seeing the film in October, I’ve been eager to talk more about it. There was just one problem: for months, the documentary couldn’t find distribution. Director Ivy Meeropol
wrote a NYT op-ed about all the challenges she faced bringing the film to viewers beyond the festival circuit, and I caught up with her recently about the long journey as well. The film first screened at the Telluride Film Festival. “People were so excited to see her there, the responses were so great—and we didn’t get any offers,” Meeropol remembers. After a lot of work, the film got one offer—and then that buyer completely ghosted. Meanwhile, last spring about five people associated with the film—from executive producers to young crew on green cards—asked to have their names scrubbed from the credits.
Eventually, Abramorama
agreed to distribute the documentary. Over the past two weekends,
Ask E. Jean started playing in New York and L.A. Audiences are showing up to watch a story that reveals a lot more about who Carroll is than her past few years as a Trump enemy—and one of few to hold Trump accountable in court. She’s had a fascinating life and career, from her time as a well-known advice columnist and talk show host to writing a biography of Hunter S. Thompson.
So what were people so afraid of? Last week, the Trump administration made clear the lengths it’s willing to go to punish Carroll. The DOJ
launched a criminal investigation of Carroll examining whether she committed perjury in lawsuits over both sexual abuse and defamation. The premise for the allegation is that she said she received no outside funding for the suit, but billionaire Reid Hoffman paid some expenses. Trump has also asked the Supreme Court to allow the DOJ to take over his appeal of the verdict, which would change Carroll’s fight from one against Trump, the individual, to one against the U.S. government on behalf of the president. And the federal government
can’t be sued for defamation.
During the process of trying to find distribution, Meeropol remembers, “No one said to me, ‘We’re not doing this because of Trump, We’re not doing this because we’re afraid of what he’ll do or we’re not doing this because of a big merger deal that he could actually affect,’ but that’s all that was in the air.” She’s careful not to make assumptions that was the only reason the film had a tough road; it’s also a really bad market for documentaries overall.
But all that is still “in the air,” as Meeropol puts it. “As far as streamers, we don’t have any offers,” she confirms. (By contrast, Amazon
paid more than $40 million for the Melania documentary.) If no streamer steps up, the filmmakers are going to work to get the film on video-on-demand for an affordable price.
If you’re in a market where the doc is playing now, I highly suggest you go see it. Otherwise, stay tuned for the next chapter in the E. Jean Carroll story.
Emma Hinchliffeemma.hinchliffe@fortune.comThe Most Powerful Women Daily newsletter is Fortune’
s daily briefing for and about the women leading the business world. Subscribe here.