Opinion Today: We analyzed hundreds of elections. Here’s how Democrats can win.
The midterms could constrain Trump, but his opponents need the right strategy. Here’s the evidence.
Opinion Today
October 20, 2025
Author Headshot

By David Leonhardt

Editorial director, Times Opinion

Next year’s midterms offer the biggest opportunity to constrain President Trump, and Democrats are understandably eager to find a winning strategy. The health of American democracy may depend on it.

With that in mind, the Times editorial board set out to understand what political strategies have won close races in recent years. We analyzed hundreds of elections and found a stark pattern: Running to the political center remains by far the most effective way to win.

We know that some of you may be skeptical. So we encourage you to read our latest editorial and weigh the evidence.

As we explain, all 17 Democrats who won races last year in places that Trump also won worked hard to signal moderation. By contrast, no current member of Congress or governor has run a truly progressive campaign and won in a swing district or state. That’s right: none.

To be clear, successful candidates don’t run to the center on every issue. Today’s moderates are often populist and combative — not sober technocrats. But they find ways to demonstrate their independence to voters fed up with both parties. If Democrats want to start winning again, they need to look at American politics as it is, not as they wish it were.

Read the editorial:

Here’s what we’re focusing on today:

Editors’ Picks

An illustration of a face with multiple colored lines below a hat with an American flag on it.

Carlos Lozada

You Caught Me. I’m Speaking Spanish.

Spanish has become a sanctioned indicator of potential criminality in the United States of America.

By Carlos Lozada

More From Opinion

The Opinions

Three Words to Help Democrats Win

Lessons from a Democrat who won in a Republican state.

play button

34 MIN LISTEN

Large crowd of people at the No Kings march in Chicago, with an inflatable Trump in the middle

Guest Essay

The Rise of the Inflatable Chicken Resistance

While what is happening to us is as serious as a guillotine, we must harness our best humorous selves in order to keep it from falling.

By Gary Shteyngart

An illustration depicting Trump surrounded by cardboard cutouts of people cheering him against a bright red background.

Frank Bruni

What JD Vance, Kash Patel and a Throw Pillow Have in Common

Trump’s flatterers are sacrificing more than just their dignity.

By Frank Bruni

The backside of a cardboard cutout of President Trump.

David French

Trump Is Dragging Us Down to His Level

The Young Republicans’ Telegram chat was revealing in so many ways.

By David French

A photo illustration featuring Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Hakeem Jeffries and Zohran Mamdani.

Guest Essay

Chris Hayes: The Democrats’ Main Problem Isn’t Their Message

Democrats’ vision for the country won’t matter unless they can get people to pay attention to it.

By Chris Hayes

At a demonstration, people holding up small American flags and a sign that reads, “No crown, no cult.”

Jamelle Bouie

Republicans Know How Vulnerable Trump Is. The Attacks on No Kings Prove It.

What explains the Republican Party’s posture toward these protests?

By Jamelle Bouie

Pete Hegseth in a suit and red tie with his hands out and mouth open.

Maureen Dowd

Fraidy-Cat at the Pentagon

Pete Hegseth can’t handle the truth.

By Maureen Dowd

An illustration depicting upside-down apartment buildings, as if in a wind storm, and a person hanging on to a door.

Guest Essay

We Found a Solution to Homelessness. Now the Trump Administration Wants to Throw It Out.

The administration’s plan would defund the very intervention that has ended homelessness for people across the country.

By Philip Mangano

A photograph of a black change purse, which is open and full of gold coins, sitting on a black surface. Smoke rises from the purse’s opening.

Guest Essay

Gambling. Investing. Gaming. There’s No Difference Anymore.

Smartphones are becoming casinos. Trump, whose son is invested in the industry, is only goosing the business.

By Jonathan D. Cohen and Isaac Rose-Berman

An illustration of four soup cans of “slop” in the style of an Andy Warhol painting.

Guest Essay

What Is Sora Slop For, Exactly?

Trying to find purpose in an endless scroll of A.I.-generated videos.

By Bobbie Johnson

A photo illustration, in stark black and white and red, of the lead characters from HBO’s “Task,” including a bearded F.B.I. agent played by Mark Ruffalo.

Guest Essay

This HBO Miniseries Gets Rural America Right

Since the first election of President Trump, Hollywood has fretted about portraying rural and red state Americans. Some new TV series show how to get it right.

By Alan Sepinwall

Virginia Roberts Giuffre before a bank of microphones.

Guest Essay

Why Virginia Roberts Giuffre Would Not Stop Talking About Jeffrey Epstein

Virginia Roberts Giuffre spent so much of her life telling the story of her abuse.

By Amy Wallace

A mother and daughter gazing at their reflection in a mirror. The mother’s reflection is of her younger self in an outfit that matches her daughter’s.

Jessica Grose

The Power of a Vintage Betsey Johnson Dress

Seeing my kid wear my bat mitzvah dress gave me a new outlook on adolescence and sentimental objects.

By Jessica Grose

An illustration depicts a shrinking and isolated American academic system walled off from its thriving Chinese counterpart.

Guest Essay

Trump’s Crackdown on Chinese Students Ignores a Startling New Reality

Shutting out China’s best minds will only push them into a homegrown Chinese research ecosystem that is eclipsing American universities.

By Bethany Allen and Jenny Wong Leung

A photo of a room with two bookshelves filled with books and a rolling chair positioned in front of them, facing the wall.

Guest Essay

My Trouble With Robots, Part 2

Telling stories is how we make sense of life and what it means to be human.

By Margaret Renkl

An illustration of a book whose cover features expiration dates ranging from the 1950s to a date in the future.

Guest Essay

The Dogged, Irrational Persistence of Literary Fiction

Literature is fragile. It serves no obvious purpose. But it is also as close to immortal as any cultural endeavor has ever been.

By Gerald Howard