President Trump's decision to prevent international students from studying at Harvard University could hurt America's economy by reducing the number of startup founders. Why it matters: Trump is aiming at Harvard, but buckshot may hit the innovation engine that America needs to stay ahead of China. The big picture: Around 44% of U.S. unicorn companies — startups valued at $1 billion or more — are founded or cofounded by immigrants from such countries as India, Canada, and Israel. - Some of those founders moved to the U.S. as children, but many came to the U.S. for school and then stayed to build their businesses.
Zoom in: Harvard gets some tech community side-eye for having less of an entrepreneurial ethos than rivals like Stanford and MIT, but the numbers don't support the critique. - According to PitchBook, Harvard is one of America's top schools for educating startup founders, ranking third for undergrads, second for grad students, and first for MBAs.
- This includes 146 U.S. unicorns, and an Axios analysis shows that at least 23 of them were founded or cofounded by international students. This cohort includes payments giant Stripe, cybersecurity firm CloudFlare, crypto brokerage FalconX, and generative AI startup Writer.
- Under Trump's edict, none of those foreign founders would have been allowed to enroll.
Zoom out: Harvard obviously is just one U.S. university out of thousands, but it has an outsized global reputation. - Trump's move could discourage other foreign students from coming here at all, particularly after Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem told Fox News that the Harvard halt "should be a warning to every other university."
- For the 7,000 or so international students currently enrolled at Harvard, some may seek to transfer to other U.S. schools — but it could be quite onerous at this point in the calendar, particularly for those working on scientific graduate degrees that are tied to specific advisers.
- Got to wonder what's going through the head of Israeli students whose visas are being revoked in the name of fighting antisemitism.
Look ahead: This dispute likely will get settled in court, with Harvard this morning suing the Trump administration over what it called "clear retaliation" against the school for "exercising its First Amendment rights." The bottom line: America's higher education system long has been a magnet for many of the world's best minds and most promising entrepreneurs. - The immediate pain might be felt by Harvard and its current international students, but we'd all share in the long-term loss.
|