An Insider look at baseball in Boston

View in browser  |  Get our newsletters

Did someone share this newsletter with you?

Subscribe here and never miss an issue!

 
MLive Subscriber Exclusive

The Fenway Rundown

Wednesday, Sept. 16, 2026

 

Hello, subscriber. Welcome to The Fenway Rundown newsletter, a weekly update from Sean McAdam, MassLive.com's Red Sox columnist, who delivers exclusively to subscribers of MassLive.com an insider’s perspective on the state of baseball in Boston.

Sean McAdam

MassLive.com

Sean McAdam | MassLive.com

 

Leading Off

Nothing is official yet, and won't be be a few more days. But as it stands, it certainly seems like we already know the following: the Red Sox are going to the postseason again, and again, they're almost certainly going to draw the New York Yankees in the wild card round.

 

There's an outside chance that could change, especially if the Yankees sweep the Rays in their upcoming regular season series and overtake them to win the division.

 

But that seems highly unlikely. And so, we get ready for Red Sox-Yankees in the Bronx, starting Sept. 29.

 

Still to be determined: the makeup of the Red Sox playoff roster. Much of that will be determined by the health of some candidates. Will Garrett Crochet be ready? How about Tanner Houck?

 

Here's what we (think we) know: The Sox will likely carry 12 pitchers and 14 position players.  Of the position players, we believe the following are locks: Adley Rutschman, Connor Wong, Willson Contreras, Nick Sogard, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, Trevor Story, Caleb Durbin, Jarren Duran, Ceddanne Rafaela, Wilyer Abreu, Roman Anthony, Mickey Gasper and Jahmai Jones.

 

That's 13, leaving spots for one more. Eli White would have definitely been included, but now it seems a foot injury could sideline him for a while.

 

That leaves utility infielder Andruw Monasterio and Nate Eaton as the final two options. For now, give the edge to Monasterio, because of his ability to cover every infield spot, but Eaton has speed, and, you may recall, started in last year's showdown.

 

Now the 12 pitchers: Sonny Gray, Ranger Suarez, Payton Tolle, Jake Bennett, Aroldis Chapman, Garrett Whitlock, Erik Miller, Tyron Guerrero, Garrett Crochet, Tanner Houck, Brayan Bello and Greg Weissert.

 

That assumes, of course, that Crochet and Houck pass the final hurdles as they return from being sidelined. Otherwise, the Sox could go with Wyatt Olds, Jovani Moran or Alec Gamboa.

 

The countdown is on. Decisions, decisions.

 

Students dressed in patriotic wear cheer on a team from the stands.

Courtesy: Getty Pictures

 

Brayan Bello won't be a starting pitcher, but he'll be part of the roster mix for the postseason as the Red Sox choose their 26 players. (AP Photos)

 

 

 

My Five Favorite Things

 

You never know what's going to happen in the postseason. Here are five unlikely Red Sox heroes from past Octobers:

 

1) Dave Roberts, 2004. Roberts was acquired at the deadline, but didn't play much of a role over the final two months — that is, until he stole second base in Game 4 of the ALCS and ignited the team's epic comeback.

 

2) Steve Pearce, 2018. A mid-season pickup for the Sox, Pearce was the team's World Series MVP as they beat the Los Angeles Dodgers.

 

3) Marty Barrett, 1986. Barrett was a steady if unspectacular regular at second base, but hit .400 in the ALCS win over the Angels and knocked in nine runs.

 

4) Mark Bellhorn, 2004. Bellhorn hit under .200 that postseason, but he made his hits count, with homers in Game 6 and Game 7 of the ALCS, then another one in Game 1 of the World Series.

 

5) Hideki Okajima, 2007. Okajima wasn't the closer — that was left to Jonathan Papelbon — but he did toss 7.1 scoreless innings in the ALDS and ALCS.

 

 

 

 

 

The Week Ahead

It's conceivable it could happen as soon as Thursday night. If not then, than sometime over the weekend.

 

But one way or another, and very soon, the Red Sox will clinch a postseason spot. And very few of us expected that would happen as recently as June.

 

As this is being written, the Sox' magic number is down to four — meaning, any combination of Red Sox wins and losses by the team's next closest to them in the wild card standings will guarantee a wild card spot for the Sox. For now, they're positioned to, for the second year in a row, clash with the New York Yankees in a best-of-three series in the Bronx.

 

But for now, let's forget about the details and the opponent.

 

It wasn't long ago that this was shaping up as very much a lost season for the Sox. They fired Alex Cora and much of his coaching staff, and tuned to Chad Tracy as their interim manager, while assembling a makeshift staff around him.

 

For some time, it didn't seem to matter. The Red Sox weren't over the .500 mark until the first series after the All-Star break. By then, a 15-game winning streak was underway and the team had salvaged the season.

 

It looks like the Red Sox will finish third in the AL East and qualify as the second wild card team. That may not seem like much for a team that had bigger aspirations, but it's certainly a preferable situation than the one they were facing mid-season.

 

If the Red Sox merely repeat last year's postseason, one-and-done performance, no one will celebrate. But the team's rebound under Tracy is, for now, reason to celebrate.

 

Remember that when, sometime in Arlington or St. Petersburg, the champagne begins to flow.

 

 

Rundown Time

Red Sox loss includes near go-ahead grand slam, poor start, new Brayan Bello role

 

Red Sox reactions: Patrick Sandoval's 44-pitch innings dooms Boston as final road trip starts

 

Red Sox rule out key reliever for rest of season, provide positive injury update on Curtis Mead

 

Red Sox' Payton Tolle accomplishes 'big goal' on off day as rookie dives into charitable efforts

 

Red Sox win includes Willson Contreras making sure fans don't boo, 'big play from Nate'

 

Red Sox' Payton Tolle, 'an electric human being,' smiles before final pitch of immaculate inning

 

Payton Tolle throws eighth immaculate innings in Red Sox team history

 

Returning Red Sox pitcher will embrace 'Swiss Army Knife' role 

 

Some Things I Think I Think: Red Sox did the right thing in retaining Andrew Bailey 

 

NOTE: If you like what you see here, you should make sure to follow MassLive's Red Sox reporters Chris Smith and Chris Cotillo and columnists Sean McAdam, Matt Vautour and Karen Guregian on Twitter. You should also bookmark MassLive's Red Sox page and like our Red Sox page on Facebook. Also, give our Red Sox podcast - also called The Fenway Rundown - a listen (more on that below)

MassLive's Red Sox Page
 

The Fenway Rundown Podcast

Co-hosts Sean McAdam and Chris Cotillo discuss Payton Tolle's rookie season and debate who is the Red Sox 2026 MVP.

 

 

CLICK HERE TO LISTEN
 

This Week In Red Sox History

On Sept. 16, 1965, pitcher Dave Morehead throws a no-hitter as the Red Sox blank the Cleveland Indians, 2-0. It would be the last no-hitter for a Red Sox pitcher until Hideo Nomo in 2000.