At Scraplanta, a nonprofit secondhand art supply and thrift store with locations in—you guessed it—Atlanta, January is usually a welcome change from the holiday rush. Executive Director Jonelle Dawkins told Retail Brew she even encourages her team, “If you want to take a vacation, January is a good time to do it.” However, in 2025, the craft table got crowded; Dawkins said January was “one of the best months that we have had,” in terms of sales, foot traffic, and donations. “Since then, we’ve just been getting exponentially more business.” One possible cause? Big box chain Joann Fabrics announced its second bankruptcy filing in January 2025 and closed all its locations nationwide by May. That means 2025 will be the first holiday crafting season without Joann since 1943, when its first store opened in Ohio. While large players like Michaels and Hobby Lobby have since moved in to claim Joann’s share of the market, crafters have also turned to small, local businesses and nonprofits selling used art supplies for a fraction of the retail price. And this December may be an indicator whether these secondhand shops could become a fixture in the craft supply market or if they’ll snap like popsicle sticks under the pressure. Keep reading here.—VWF |