Green Daily
Plus, an update on Germany's coal goals
View in browser
Bloomberg

BlackRock Inc., the world’s largest money manager, is facing very different ESG pressures on opposites sides of the Atlantic. While Chief Executive Officer Larry Fink was an early advocate of environmental, social and governance investing, his firm has lost business from some US state entities in recent years amid a wave of anti-ESG sentiment. Now one of Europe’s biggest pension funds is retreating from BlackRock for not thinking enough about the environment. Read more below and get the full story on Bloomberg.com.

Also, check out reporter Petra Sorge’s latest story on the role market forces are playing in Germany’s quest to switch off coal power. For unlimited access to climate and energy news, please subscribe

BlackRock’s ESG dilemma  

By Frances Schwartzkopff

BlackRock Inc. has lost a mandate worth €14.5 billion ($17 billion) with one of the largest pension funds in the Netherlands, amid concerns the world’s biggest money manager isn’t acting in the best interests of clients when it comes to climate risk.

PFZW, which oversees about €250 billion ($290 billion), will instead rely on Robeco, Man Numeric, Acadian, Lazard, Schroders, M&G, UBS and PGGM to oversee an equity portfolio worth some €50 billion, a spokesperson for the pensions manager told Bloomberg on Wednesday.

A BlackRock representative said the asset manager “noted PFZW’s redemption in the first half of 2025,” adding that it continues to help clients, including those in the Netherlands, meet their sustainable investing goals. PFZW has “always voted their portfolio with BlackRock themselves,” and BlackRock offers “eligible clients” the option to “participate in the stewardship of their assets,” the representative said.

BlackRock headquarters in New York. Photographer: Bing Guan/Bloomberg

PFZW is the latest asset owner to voice discontent with US money managers that have retreated from climate alliances amid an all-out assault on net zero policies by the White House. PME, another Dutch pensions manager, told Bloomberg earlier this year it’s reviewing its mandate with BlackRock, valued at some €5 billion.

“PFZW has been developing a new investment strategy where financial performance, risk and sustainability are weighed equally within the framework of a total portfolio approach,” the fund said in an emailed comment.

Its mandate with BlackRock was valued at €14.5 billion at the end of March, which is the latest period for which PFZW was able to provide a figure, the spokesperson said. PFZW said it continues to invest in BlackRock money market funds.

Dutch pension funds have been under pressure from a local nonprofit, Fossil Free Netherlands, to end their ties with BlackRock. The Break with BlackRock initiative asked savers to urge their pension funds to act, and thousands have done so, according to the nonprofit’s website.

Dutch media outlet NRC Handelsblad reported earlier that PFZW was making changes to its approach to asset management that included dropping BlackRock.

PME plans to decide on its BlackRock mandate before the end of the year, a spokesperson said on Wednesday, noting that the firm has had “several” exchanges with the US asset manager over the past year.

Back in May, PME’s senior strategist for responsible investing, Daan Spaargaren, told Bloomberg the €57 billion pension manager’s concern was that BlackRock wasn’t doing enough to distance itself from the anti-climate rhetoric of the administration of US President Donald Trump.

BlackRock and other US asset managers “aren’t condemning what Trump is doing and how he is operating and how he is handling issues like climate change and demolishing the judiciary,” Spaargaren said at the time. “We are worried about that.”

Read the full story with updates on Bloomberg.com. 

    The US retreats on ESG

    $20 billion
    This is how much investors pulled from US ESG funds in 2024, according to Morningstar Inc., compared with outflows of just over $13 billion a year earlier. By contrast, traditional funds pulled in $740 billion of net new money.

    For some, EU rules still trump all

    "America was never a center for sustainability."
     Lubomila Jordanova
    Co-founder and chief executive officer of Plan A, a sustainability data company in Berlin
     Jordanova says Plan A's clients, which include BMW, KFC and the fashion brand Chloé, use EU rules as the driving force for their environmental practices around the world. She says some of her clients, including the vacation rental company HomeToGo, require their US and Asian subsidiaries to report their sustainability data following EU standards.

    Are market forces enough to wean Germany off coal?

    By Petra Sorge

    Germany, long the European Union’s biggest greenhouse gas emitter, is phasing down coal faster than expected. The country’s energy regulator announced this week that it won’t need to order the shutdown of any coal-fired power plants for a second year in a row, because operators are already voluntarily switching off unprofitable units.

    The news is providing the latest evidence that Europe’s carbon pricing regime is helping to reduce emissions across the bloc. Under the EU Emissions Trading System, utilities must buy CO2 allowances, which have traded between €60 ($69) and €84 ($98) a metric ton this year, and are now about €74. Those costs have squeezed margins for coal stations.

    Since 2020, Germany has shut about 8.2 gigawatts of coal capacity “as mounting pressure from carbon prices rendered these plants uneconomic,” said Kesavarthiniy Savarimuthu, head of European Power Markets at BNEF. Another 3 gigawatts of the country's coal capacity are slated for closure within the next five years as rising emissions costs continue to weigh on coal plant profitability, she added. 

    Yet at least 23 gigawatts of coal power still remain active in Germany’s energy mix, with a government phaseout target not scheduled until 2038. A previous German government’s pledge to bring that forward to 2030 hasn’t been repeated by current Chancellor Friedrich Merz’s administration, which has frustrated climate campaigners.

    A lignite coal-fired power plant, in Peitz, Germany, in  2023.  Photographer: Krisztian Bocsi/Bloomberg

    The picture is complicated by energy security. Coal was ramped up to help Germany through the energy crisis kicked off by Russia’s curtailment of pipeline gas in 2022. It has also seen a boost earlier this year during several windless periods, when wind farms produced less power. And during the winter — when less favorable weather conditions meet higher energy demand — coal generation will likely again see an increase, said Nicolas Leicht, energy economist at energy think tank Aurora Energy Research.

    At the same time, the last several months have seen a steep decline in natural gas prices, which now have reached a level close to the time before Russia’s attack on Ukraine in 2022. “That’s making gas-fired power plants more profitable, compared to coal stations,” said Leicht.

    Renewables are expanding at speed: In the first six months of the year, 2.2 gigawatts of onshore wind turbines were taken online, a pace not seen since 2017. Solar deployment is accelerating too, helped by fast-track permitting. In August, the share of coal-fired electricity produced in Germany reached its lowest level in over 60 years, according to the think tank Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy Systems ISE.

    Yet the declining coal trend is also connected to overall shrinking power demand in a country that still grapples with a stagnating economy. There are worries that rising carbon prices will only add to other costs of doing business in Germany. Michael Vassiliadis, the head of the mining, chemical, and energy trade union IGBCE, said at a press conference last week that energy-intensive industries should get a reprieve on having to buy as many CO2 certificates because the situation is “killing our businesses.” He was echoing a similar demand from steelmaker ThyssenKrupp.

    The government faces a dilemma. Creating exceptions and loopholes in the emissions trading system would not only penalize companies that invested in cleaner processes., but it would also blunt the very price signals pushing coal off the grid. It could also create volatility, with coal plants bouncing back whenever carbon costs ease.

    Another uncertainty is security of supply. Germany shuttered its last nuclear stations two years ago and still lacks firm back-up capacity for dark, windless days. Plans to build a new fleet of gas-fired power stations are sparking warnings from climate activists that this would simply create a new fossil fuel dependence. However, delays on new capacity also make it “less feasible” that all coal-fired power plants can be taken off the grid in time for Germany’s 2038 deadline, according to Aurora analyst Leicht.

    For Europe, the German case is instructive. Carbon pricing and cheap renewables are proving effective market levers to drive out coal. But the lack of a reliable and ready backup, along with political and industrial pressures, could keep coal plants in operation longer than expected -- casting doubt on whether market forces alone can get Europe’s biggest carbon polluter in line with the bloc’s broader climate ambitions.

    Read more on this story on Bloomberg.com. 

    More from Green

    Centrus Energy Corp.'s facility in Ohio is large enough to house 11,000 centrifuges, the machines that create nuclear fuel. Right now, there are just 16 spinning away to produce a type of next-generation enriched uranium. But the remaining space could eventually be filled with many more.

    Rising interest in nuclear energy from both the Trump administration and consumers — notably power-hungry tech companies trying to compete in artificial intelligence — is spurring dozens of companies in the US to develop innovative, advanced reactor designs.

    Many of those prototypes will require Haleu, or high-assay low-enriched uranium, and that's where Centrus comes in. Haleu supply is currently limited, and demand even more so, but that may be beginning to change.

    Haleu is critical for advanced reactor designs, and Centrus is the only US company approved to make it. The question now for Centrus is when to invest in expanding production. The Energy Department announced support for 11 advanced reactor pilot projects this month, including the Radiant test system, and many of them will require Haleu. But pilots are typically one-off projects that don’t always translate into long-term sales contracts that might justify a major investment in production capacity for Centrus.

    What will it take to turn Centrus’ empty halls into a cornerstone of America’s nuclear future? Read the full story on Bloomberg.com. 

    A view inside the Centrus facility in Ohio. Photographer: Jed Rosenberg/Bloomberg

    Coal India Ltd. has sought bids to build 5 gigawatts of renewable projects. The world’s largest producer of coal is looking to diversify its portfolio in view of a possible decline in future demand of the commodity. 

    A group of private investors have launched the All Aboard Coalition to help address the fundraising challenge of climate tech startups on the brink of commercialization.

    Denmark is targeting as much as 10 billion kroner ($1.56 billion), in what looks set to be the first sovereign green bond to be aligned with the European Union’s new standards.

    More from Bloomberg

    • Business of Food for a weekly look at how the world feeds itself in a changing economy and climate, from farming to supply chains to consumer trends
    • Hyperdrive for expert insight into the future of cars
    • Energy Daily for a daily guide to the energy and commodities markets that power the global economy
    • CityLab Daily for top stories, ideas and solutions, from cities around the world
    • Tech In Depth for analysis and scoops about the business of technology

    Explore all Bloomberg newsletters.

    Follow Us

    Like getting this newsletter? Subscribe to Bloomberg.com for unlimited access to trusted, data-driven journalism and subscriber-only insights.


    Want to sponsor this newsletter? Get in touch here.

    You received this message because you are subscribed to Bloomberg's Green Daily newsletter. If a friend forwarded you this message, sign up here to get it in your inbox.
    Unsubscribe
    Bloomberg.com
    Contact Us
    Bloomberg L.P.
    731 Lexington Avenue,
    New York, NY 10022
    Ads Powered By Liveintent Ad Choices