After a marathon trial and more than six days of deliberations, a jury yesterday declared Erin Patterson guilty of murdering three people and attempting to kill another by feeding them poisonous death cap mushrooms in a beef wellington.
One of the case’s key questions was the motive: why would Patterson murder her family and friends? As experts Rick Sarre and Ben Livings explain, the prosecution didn’t need to outline a motive for the jury to convict – indeed, they did so without one.
Much of the action during the 11-week trial was outside the courtroom, with the case spurring podcasts, international media attention and even YouTube videos from so-called “body language experts” assessing innocence or guilt.
Why the obsession with this case? Criminologist Xanthe Mallett says there are several factors, from the small-town setting to the apparent mundanity of a family lunch.
But she reminds us that despite the media frenzy, the case has now closed on three tragic deaths.
|
|
Erin Cooper-Douglas
Deputy Politics + Society Editor
|
|
|
Rick Sarre, University of South Australia; Ben Livings, University of South Australia
The jury has delivered its unanimous verdict in one of the most-watched court cases ever. Here’s what was at play legally and what happens now.
|
Xanthe Mallett, CQUniversity Australia
Since the news broke in 2023, the ‘mushroom case’ has taken on a life of its own. What made it so compelling?
|
Thalia Anthony, University of Technology Sydney; Eddie Cubillo, The University of Melbourne
The inquest findings did not deliver a crushing blow to racial violence in the NT Police. It is a missed opportunity that will likely have devastating consequences.
|
Erica Kuligowski, RMIT University
How ready is Australia for its next sudden flood? And what could help to encourage people to leave while there’s still time?
|
Jeremie M Bracka, RMIT University
The Yoorrook Justice Commission reports are powerful and historic. But the question remains: will they change anything?
|
Michelle Grattan, University of Canberra
Albanese seems to find himself on eggshells whenever the American relationship comes up, with his failure to secure a meeting with Trump becoming its own story.
|
Wendy Hunt, Murdoch University
The chef and TV presenter Peter Russell-Clarke has died age 89. He changed the way Australians thought about food.
|
Kathryn Shine, Curtin University
Barbara Demick’s report on the links between China’s stolen children and international adoptions started a life-changing chain of extraordinary events.
|
Victoria Minson, Australian Catholic University; Amanda Telford, Australian Catholic University
The winter school holidays can be a tricky time. Parents are juggling work and chilly conditions make it easy for kids to end up on the couch with multiple devices.
|
Wesley Morgan, UNSW Sydney; Gillian Moon, UNSW Sydney
As Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen tours the Pacific this week, nations’ legal obligations to phase out fossil fuels are becoming undeniable.
|
Health + Medicine
|
-
Joya Kemper, University of Canterbury; Amanda Palmer, University of South Carolina; Bodo Lang, Te Kunenga ki Pūrehuroa – Massey University; Chris Bullen, University of Auckland, Waipapa Taumata Rau; George Laking, University of Auckland, Waipapa Taumata Rau; Jamie Brown, UCL; Lion Shahab, UCL; Natalie Walker, Flinders University; Vili Nosa, University of Auckland, Waipapa Taumata Rau
Using vapes for more than two years and with nicotine concentrations above 3% is linked to higher dependence, making it more difficult to stop.
-
Samantha Chan, WEHI (Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research) ; Jo Douglass, The University of Melbourne
Some studies indicate children with pets may be less likely to have allergies. But the evidence can be tricky to interpret.
-
Alix Mellor, Monash University
This arrangement can have benefits. But it doesn’t have to be permanent, and doesn’t have to mean the end of intimacy.
-
Victoria Barclay-Timmis, University of Southern Queensland
Rejection sensitivity in ADHD can make everyday feedback feel overwhelming. Here’s why it happens and how to manage it with care.
|
|
Business + Economy
|
-
Glenn Banks, Te Kunenga ki Pūrehuroa – Massey University
The big financial returns from mining often flow overseas. Here are four ways the government could ensure the country benefits more if it expands mining.
|
|
Science + Technology
|
-
Bronwyn Cumbo, University of Technology Sydney
Data centres promise to boost the economy. But the everyday realities of communities living near them aren’t as optimistic.
-
Samuel Cornell, UNSW Sydney; Daniel Angus, Queensland University of Technology; T.J. Thomson, RMIT University
Your social media is no longer a personal space. It may be used by governments to determine whether you fit with their values.
|
|
Your Say
|
Grade inflation
"As an employer, we included practical 'trial days' during our hiring process and it didn’t take long to notice a wide variation in capability of graduates from different schools with similar grades. Passing a student who has not achieved the required skill level can be deadly in medical, paramedical and other professions. Grade inflation only sends the problem further down the employment line and degrades the reputation of the school among employers."
Karin Mogg 
It’s on the government
"In the wake of Melbourne’s childcare abuse allegations, I felt your story about what parents can do was a terrible choice and very reactionary. It places unfair onus on individual parents to stop their children being abused! It’s not up to individuals, it’s up to governments to strictly regulate childcare centres, childcare workers need to be paid more and be expected to have higher levels of education."
Sarah Howlett-Sands
Time to rethink for-profit childcare and aged care
"I think providing high quality childcare and aged care aren’t compatible with for-profit business models. Both these industries are very labour intensive and therefore, their ability to provide safe environments is compromised because mostly they’re understaffed, despite receiving government subsidies. To maximise profit in these industries and still make them affordable for the general population, labour costs would need to be kept as low as possible. Safe, enriching environments for both children and the elderly are only possible in care settings when they're sufficiently staffed."
Lynne Pantaur 
We'd love to hear from you. You can email us with your thoughts on our stories and each day we'll publish an edited selection.
|
|
|
Charles Darwin University
Darwin NT, Australia
•
Full Time
|
|
University of Tasmania
Hobart TAS, Australia
•
Full Time
|
|
University of Technology, Sydney
Sydney NSW, Australia
•
Full Time
|
|
Charles Darwin University
Darwin NT, Australia
•
Contract
|
|
| |