Businessweek Daily
It involves Argentina and peanuts
View in browser
Bloomberg

The word of the day is “tariffs” as the world awaits specifics on what exactly President Donald Trump is planning next in his trade war. Here, Stacey Vanek Smith has some history about what happened when Argentina issued strict levies. Plus: Changes in Elon Musk’s empire, and why China is pushing vocational schools. If this email was forwarded to you, click here to sign up.

On this “Liberation Day,” as Donald Trump has named it, before a 4 p.m. White House announcement on the president’s long-touted tariffs, I can’t stop thinking about Argentine peanuts.

It might sound strange, but peanuts played a major role in Argentina’s 2011 foray into protectionist tariffs. Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, the president at the time, had a plan to make Argentina great again. A key part was bringing manufacturing back to the country. For some industries, this meant tariffs of 30% or higher on imported goods. In other cases—such as cellphones—it meant you couldn’t sell your wares in Argentina unless you made them in the country. (Stores in Buenos Aires stopped selling iPhones, forcing Argentines to smuggle the gadgets into the country when they returned from Miami, Madrid or elsewhere. Argentina still imposes tariffs on foreign-made phones.)

Foreign automakers could export cars to Argentina but with a catch: They couldn’t add to the country’s trade deficit. This presented a major problem. The companies would need to start manufacturing in Argentina or find something they could import from the country to offset the cost of the vehicles they wanted to sell there. And here’s where things started to get really strange.

Porsche wasn’t about to start building in Argentina. So its distributor started buying and importing millions of dollars worth of Argentine olives and malbec wine to balance out the Porsches it was selling. BMW bought enormous quantities of rice. Subaru gobbled up chicken feed. And Hyundai and Mitsubishi jumped head first into the peanut business. The auto giants cut deals with peanut farmers in central Argentina and began shipping tens of millions of dollars worth of peanuts to Asia and Europe. Global peanut prices soared.

A Fiat truck plan in Córdoba, Argentina, in 2001. Photographer: Marecelo Caceras/AFP/Getty Images

The whole thing was nuts, but it worked for a while: Foreign companies were investing millions in the country. Some, like Fiat and Renaut, were building factories and hiring local workers, while others were bankrolling the nation’s vintners, soybean growers, chicken feed purveyors and peanut farmers. The Argentine economy flourished and so did consumer spending—car sales in 2010 and 2011 set records—growing almost 30% a year. The trade deficit dropped, employment rose, and soon publications like the New York Times and the Guardian were toasting the triumph of Kirchner’s economic plan. (The Times labeled it “Argentina’s Turnaround Tango.”)

Then came the dip. All of the factory building and peanut farming got expensive, and carmakers began passing those costs on to consumers. Inflation started to climb. In 2011, a typical car in Argentina cost about $60,000; a year later, the price was more like $100,000. Sales slumped. At the same time, in-country carmakers were having trouble importing the materials and parts they needed, which led to quality issues, outdated models, paused production and, eventually, layoffs. Soon the country was in a full-on economic crisis, which it’s still climbing out of.

So you can understand why, last week, when Hyundai announced plans to spend $6 billion to buy a steel plant in Louisiana to get around tariffs, my mind immediately went to peanuts. Trump celebrated the news as “a clear demonstration that tariffs very strongly work.”

While it’s unclear exactly what Trump’s broader tariffs will include, levies of 25% on imported vehicles are scheduled to begin at 12:01 New York time on Thursday. And that has me worried.

Of course, every leader of every country wants to control the economy. Who wouldn’t want to have some power over the stock market, food prices, the unemployment rate or economic growth? But history has shown us that trying to corral animal spirits comes at a punishing price. Large-scale economic controls often end in disaster. Sure, it might start off with shiny factories and cheering crowds, but before you know it, you’ve got a South Korean car company selling overpriced Argentine peanuts to France, and an economy in crisis.

On the bright side, I have the perfect snack suggestion for today.

Related from Trumponomics: The Roots of Trump’s Global Trade War

In Brief

On the Latest Elon, Inc. Podcast

Photo illustration by 731; Photos: Getty images (1); NASA (1)

On Friday night, news broke that Elon Musk was merging his company X with his company xAI—a move that Elon, Inc. predicted last year. In a new episode of the podcast, social media reporter Kurt Wager, Elon Musk reporter Dana Hull, Bloomberg Businessweek senior writer Max Chafkin and host David Papadopoulos talk about what Friday night’s news means for Musk’s financial world and what might be in his political future, in light of the Wisconsin Supreme Court vote.

Listen and subscribe to Elon, Inc. on Apple, Spotify, iHeart and the Bloomberg Terminal.

Related:

China’s Blue-Collar Path for Students

Illustration: Jentwo for Bloomberg Businessweek

Every summer, millions of young Chinese graduate from the country’s increasingly strong network of four-year universities. But lately, many can’t find a good job once they leave school, so they end up becoming delivery drivers, livestreamers and even “professional children”—moving back in with mom and dad, who pay them to do chores. At the same time, tens of millions of positions in fields such as manufacturing, information technology and health care will go unfilled this year for lack of qualified candidates. “Low-level manufacturing jobs can be automated, but there’s a severe shortage of skilled blue-collar workers who can write code or operate machine tools,” says Dan Wang, China director of the Eurasia Group.

The disconnect has officials from President Xi Jinping on down urging young people to forgo a college degree and instead attend a vocational school. These offer three-year diplomas and help develop skills for machinery technicians and operators, robotics engineers, nurses and myriad other jobs.

Xi needs a pipeline of skilled laborers to keep the factories humming, of course, but with 1 in 6 youths unemployed, he also faces rising social discontent. Only 45% of the university class of 2024 had received job offers by April, when most campus recruitment ends, according to employment search website Zhaopin Ltd. For graduates of vocational colleges—which often have partnerships with companies that offer internships and placements—the figure rises to 57%. “There’s a structural mismatch between the job market and education,” says Kelvin Lam, an analyst at Pantheon Macroeconomics. “New graduates don’t want to go back to the factories.”

It’s a tough sell persuading parents to send their kids to vocational schools instead of universities, writes Lucille Liu, even when it’s a national priority: China Tells Kids to Study Manufacturing to Fill Factory Jobs

Buying Opportunity

29%
That’s how much Manhattan home sales jumped in the first quarter, compared with last year, with the median price reaching $1.165 million. Buyers have been taking advantage of small dips in mortgage rates over the past few months.

Rewriting the Energy-Sector Playbook

“All of this belies thinking that’s completely bonkers. Just because you have a president that’s trying to ignore the science and economics of climate change, it’s bizarre to think you can avoid the massive climate-related or climate-accelerated physical disasters that we’re seeing.”
Catherine McKenna
Canada’s former minister of environment and climate change and chair of the United Nations secretary general’s expert group on private-sector net zero targets
Wall Street’s unanimity on the need to limit climate change is collapsing, sparking a reset in the $1.4 trillion global market for energy finance. Read the full story here.

More From Bloomberg

Like Businessweek Daily? Check out these newsletters:

  • Business of Space for inside stories of investments beyond Earth
  • CFO Briefing for what finance leaders need to know
  • CityLab Daily for today’s top stories, ideas and solutions from cities around the world
  • Tech In Depth for analysis and scoops about the business of technology
  • Green Daily for the latest in climate news, zero-emission tech and green finance

Explore all Bloomberg newsletters.

Follow Us

Like getting this newsletter? Subscribe to Bloomberg.com for unlimited access to trusted, data-driven journalism and subscriber-only insights.

Want to sponsor this newsletter? Get in touch here.

You received this message because you are subscribed to Bloomberg's Businessweek Daily newsletter. If a friend forwarded you this message, sign up here to get it in your inbox.
Unsubscribe
Bloomberg.com
Contact Us
Bloomberg L.P.
731 Lexington Avenue,
New York, NY 10022
Ads Powered By Liveintent Ad Choices